Share This:

What Kind of Fence Should I Get?

A good fence provides you with added curb appeal and legitimate yard safety for kids and pets alike. Good news: you have more choices for your new fence than ever before. That’s why one of the most common questions we hear is, “What kind of fence should I get?”

Knowing the differences between the most popular fencing materials can help make your decision-making process easier, your installation smoother, and can ultimately can save you money in the long run! Whether it is aluminum, wood, or vinyl, your fence will greatly impact your sense of home and your new fence budget. Stick around for our easy-to-use fence material comparison guide. Use the information now while you’re searching for your perfect fence – or bookmark this page for later when you are ready!

Long-lasting vinyl fence in backyard


Smucker’s Fence Material Comparison

Backyard and front yard fences do more than just accentuate your home – they protect it. Depending on what benefits of fences are your highest priority will determine what kind of fence you should get. Below we are highlighting three of Smucker Fencing’s top selling materials in an easy-to-use fence material comparison guide. We never want you to have to ask, “What kind of fence should I get?” ever again!

Without further ado, let’s dig into today’s topic:


Wood Fenceing: Low Price, High Value  

Wooden picket budget fence

Wooden fences provide a warm welcome to homeowners without breaking the bank. Wooden fences never take too much convincing to install – they’ve been around for decades and most people have grown up with one in their own yards!

Perhaps the most standard fencing option on the market, wood is ideal for the homeowner who doesn’t mind putting in a little extra maintenance to keep initial costs down. While there is annual staining and maintenance involved, it’s no problem for anyone who doesn’t mind rolling up their sleeves every once in awhile! When completing your own fence material comparison, consider the following about wood:

  • Comes with about a 15-year lifespan
  • Is extremely affordable
  • Boasts a natural, rustic style
  • Will require regular maintenance
  • Has a short lifespan compared to other options


Vinyl Fencing: Low Risk, High Privacy  

Budget-friendly vinyl fencing in yard

For homeowners who value privacy, vinyl fences are the ultimate option! Our fence material comparison puts vinyl fences at the top for qualities such as durability, security, and a long lifespan.

While they’re known for their classic American style, vinyl fences can also be quite versatile in design — from pickets to privacy in a realm of beautiful colors. Vinyl fencing may cost more than wood upfront, but given its extremely low maintenance costs and long lifespan, vinyl fencing tends to be cheaper than many other options in the long run. To summarize the pros and cons of vinyl fencing:

  • Has a 50+ year lifespan
  • Offers great vision privacy
  • Comes in more colors than ever
  • Is a very popular and common design
  • Requires annual light cleaning with soap and water


Aluminum Fencing: Low Maintenance, High Style

Strong Aluminum Fence by Pool

What aluminum fences lack in opaque privacy they make up for in gorgeous solidity. When completing a fence material comparison, aluminum comes out on top for strength, sleek style, and maintenance. Aluminum is famous for its extreme durability which means it can stand up against big dogs, intruders, or persistent kids. Because it is considered a new, modern material, aluminum fences are now available in new gorgeous colors!

If you’re not a fan of yardwork, this is the fence for you! While we all love a maintenance-free product, this luxury comes at a price – the highest price of these three in our fence material comparison, in fact. To those still wondering, “What kind of fence should I get?”, here is the overall breakdown of aluminum fencing:

  • 50+ year lifespan
  • Is a true no-maintenance fencing option
  • Offers the most color and style options
  • Elevated curb appeal and home value
  • Highest priced fence material
  • Lacks opaque privacy


Stop Asking “What Kind of Fence Should I Get?”

A professionally installed fence gives you the true sense of home that we all desire. But continuously asking yourself, “What kind of fence should I get?” delays your process entirely! That’s where our experts come in.

At Smucker Fencing, we’re here for you every step of the way: from pre-order research to the final piece of cleanup. We hope you found our fence material comparison helpful, but if you still have questions or would like to get your free price estimate, please feel free to call or contact us!

Contact Us

How Can We Help You?
Share This:
Request a Quote